Accordion Shutters vs. Impact Windows: Which Is Right for a Miami Home?
Both pass the same county tests. The real differences are price, what you do before a storm, and how the house lives the rest of the year.

Both protect an opening and both can earn the insurance credit. Accordion shutters cost about $20 to $40 per square foot installed and take a few minutes to close. Impact windows cost about $50 to $100 per square foot, need no action before a storm, and replace your old windows. Choose shutters for value and impact glass for convenience, or mix the two.
This is one of the first questions homeowners ask. We install both, so we have no reason to push you one way. Here is how they compare.
Side by side
| Accordion shutters | Impact windows and doors | |
|---|---|---|
| Published 2026 price, installed | About $20 to $40 per sq ft | About $50 to $100 per sq ft |
| 250 sq ft of openings | About $5,000 to $10,000 | About $12,500 to $25,000 |
| Before a storm | Close and lock each one | Nothing |
| Light during a storm | Dark inside when closed | Normal daylight |
| Day-to-day look | Folded stacks beside each opening | No visible hardware |
| Replaces old windows | No | Yes |
| After a hit | The shutter may dent, and the glass behind is protected | The glass may crack and need replacing, and the opening stays sealed |
| Upkeep | Rinse and lubricate a few times a year | Normal window care |
| Insurance credit | Can qualify | Can qualify |
Prices are published market ranges, not our price list.
How each one works
An accordion shutter is a folding aluminum wall that rides on tracks above and below the opening. See how accordion shutters work.
Impact glass is a sandwich: two panes bonded to a tough clear layer between them, in a reinforced frame.
- Outer pane of glass
- Clear interlayer bonded between the panes
- Inner pane of glass
- Reinforced frame, anchored to the wall
- After an impact the glass can crack, but it stays in the frame
Where shutters win
- Price. About a third of the cost for the same openings.
- Your windows stay. If your windows are in good shape, there is no reason to throw them away.
- Speed. A shutter job is simpler to permit, build, and install than a window replacement.
- The glass survives. The shutter takes the hit, not the window.
- Security when you travel. A locked shutter is a visible barrier.
Where impact windows win
- Nothing to do. No closing, no opening, no one to call if you are out of town.
- Daylight. You are not sitting in the dark during a storm or a long outage.
- Year-round benefits. Less outside noise and a hard target for break-ins, every day.
- Appearance. Nothing mounted on the walls.
- New windows. If yours are old, leaky, or hard to open, you fix that at the same time.
Want a price for your own home?
We install and repair accordion shutters across Miami-Dade County. Estimates are free and there is no obligation.
Day-to-day differences
Storms are a few days a year. The rest of the time, the two behave very differently.
| Accordion shutters | Impact windows | |
|---|---|---|
| Outside noise | No change when open | Laminated glass cuts noise |
| Sun and fading | No change when open | The interlayer blocks most ultraviolet light |
| Break-ins | A barrier only when closed and locked | Hard to break through at all times |
| Power outage after a storm | Open the shutters for light and air | Nothing to do |
| When you travel | Someone has to close them | Nothing to do |
If those everyday benefits matter to you, they are part of what the higher price buys.
The insurance question
The wind mitigation form records the level of protection on your openings. It does not ask whether that protection is glass or a shutter. Approved accordion shutters on every opening and approved impact glass on every opening can earn the same kind of credit. See insurance discounts.
Which should you choose?
Shutters make more sense if:
- Your windows are in good condition
- Budget is the priority
- Someone is usually home to close them, or you have help
- You want the whole house protected now, not in phases
Impact windows make more sense if:
- Your windows need replacing anyway
- You travel during hurricane season
- Closing shutters is physically hard for you
- Your HOA or your own taste rules out visible shutters
Mixing them
Many Miami-Dade homes do both. Three common plans:
- Impact front door, shutters everywhere else. The door is the hardest opening to shutter well.
- Impact glass on the street side, shutters on the sides and back. Appearance where it shows, value where it does not.
- Shutters now, windows later. Protect everything this season and replace windows as the budget allows. The shutters keep protecting the openings you have not reached.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need shutters if I have impact windows?
No. Impact windows are approved protection by themselves. Some owners add shutters to protect the glass itself, but it is not required.
Which lasts longer?
Both last for decades when they are maintained. Shutters need cleaning and lubrication. Impact windows need the same care as any window.
Which adds more to resale value?
Buyers tend to notice new impact windows more. For insurance, what matters is that every opening has approved protection.
Can I install shutters over impact windows later?
Yes. Shutters mount on the wall around the opening and work with any window behind them.
Miami Accordion Shutters installs and repairs hurricane shutters across Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Kendall, Doral, Coral Gables, Homestead, Cutler Bay, Miami Beach, and nearby communities. Call (786) 201-1300 for a free estimate.