Comparing shutter types

Accordion vs. Roll-Down Shutters: Cost, Looks, and Daily Use

Both are permanent, and both close in minutes. They differ in how they move, what they cost, and how they look when open.

Black accordion shutters being installed on a two-story house
Upstairs is where the choice between these two usually comes up.
Quick answer

Accordion shutters fold to the sides of the opening and cost about $20 to $40 per square foot installed. Roll-down shutters roll up into a box above the opening, cost about $30 to $65 per square foot, and can close from inside with a crank or a motor. Accordions are the better value, and roll-downs are the easier ones to operate.

These are the two permanent shutter types that most Miami-Dade homeowners compare. We install both.

Side by side

Accordion Roll-down
Published 2026 price, installed About $20 to $40 per sq ft About $30 to $65 per sq ft
Moves Sideways, on top and bottom tracks Up and down, in side rails
When open Folded stacks at the sides Rolled into a box above
Operated from Outside, or inside through an open window Inside or outside, by crank, strap, or motor
Moving parts Wheels, hinges, a lock Curtain, axle, crank gear or motor
Power needed None Only if motorized
Upkeep Clean tracks, lubricate Clean rails, service the operator

Prices are published market ranges, not our price list.

How they look

An open accordion shutter leaves a vertical stack of blades on one or both sides of the window. On a wide opening, the stacks are wider.

Diagram of an accordion shutter with its parts numbered
The parts of an accordion shutter, seen from outside with the shutter half closed.
  1. Top track, anchored to the wall
  2. Blades: interlocking aluminum slats
  3. Stack: where the blades fold when open
  4. Center mates and lock
  5. Bottom track, or sill
  6. Wheels that carry the blades

An open roll-down leaves the sides clear and puts a horizontal box above the opening.

Diagram of a roll-down shutter with its parts numbered
The parts of a roll-down shutter, shown half lowered.
  1. Housing box, where the curtain rolls up
  2. Curtain of interlocking slats
  3. Side guide rails
  4. Bottom bar and lock
  5. Hand crank, strap, or motor

Neither is invisible. Which looks better depends on the house. Color helps both. See the color guide.

Where accordion shutters win

  • Price. About a third less for the same opening.
  • Simplicity. No motor, no gears, no electrical work.
  • Wide openings. They cover sliding doors and patios without the storm bars that wide roll-downs can need.
  • Power outages. There is nothing to fail.

Where roll-down shutters win

  • Ease. A crank or a button from inside the house.
  • Upper floors. No ladder and no reaching through a window.
  • Partial use. They can be lowered partway for shade or privacy.
  • Clear sides. Nothing stacked beside the window.

Want a price for your own home?

We install and repair accordion shutters across Miami-Dade County. Estimates are free and there is no obligation.

Request a free estimate Call (786) 201-1300

The same house, priced both ways

Take a two-story home with 150 square feet of openings downstairs and 100 square feet upstairs, at published 2026 prices.

Plan Estimated cost
Accordion shutters everywhere $5,000 to $10,000
Roll-downs everywhere $7,500 to $16,250
Accordion downstairs, roll-downs upstairs $6,000 to $12,500

The mixed plan puts the extra money only where it removes a ladder. These are market ranges, not our price list.

Choosing by opening

You do not have to pick one for the whole house.

Opening Usual choice
Ground-floor windows Accordion
Sliding glass doors and patios Accordion
Second-story windows you cannot reach Roll-down, or accordion operated from inside
A window someone has trouble reaching or pulling Roll-down

See shutters for second-story windows.

Three quick tests

  • The ladder test. If closing a shutter would take a ladder, choose a roll-down, or an accordion shutter you can reach from inside.
  • The hands test. Sliding an accordion shutter takes a firm pull. If that motion is hard for whoever closes the house, use roll-downs on the openings that person will handle.
  • The outage test. Picture three days without power after a storm. Accordion shutters and manual roll-downs open either way. A motorized roll-down needs an override.

Both count the same

Both are permanent shutters under the county's permit rules, both need a product approval, and both can earn the insurance credit when every opening is protected.

From our project notes: Black Accordion Shutters on a Two-Story Home

Frequently asked questions

Are roll-down shutters stronger than accordion shutters?

Both must pass the same Miami-Dade tests to be approved. Strength for your opening comes from choosing an approved product and installing it as its approval shows.

Which is easier to close?

Roll-downs, especially motorized ones. Accordion shutters are still quick: pull the two halves together and lock them.

Can I have both on the same house?

Yes. It is a common way to put the money where it helps most.

Miami Accordion Shutters installs and repairs hurricane shutters across Miami-Dade County, including Miami, Hialeah, Kendall, Doral, Coral Gables, Homestead, Cutler Bay, Miami Beach, and nearby communities. Call (786) 201-1300 for a free estimate.

Free Estimate

Get a free estimate for your home

Tell us about your windows and doors and we will follow up to schedule your estimate.

  • Free estimate anywhere in Miami-Dade
  • Licensed and insured
  • Miami-Dade approved (NOA) products
  • We handle the permit
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Hablamos español

Prefer to talk now? Call (786) 201-1300

Request a Free Estimate

Tell us about your home and we will follow up.

Prefer to talk now? (786) 201-1300

Call
Now
Call (786) 201-1300